Reviewing Carbonite

by Pete Abilla on February 10, 2007

Enjoy this article? Please SUBSCRIBE to receive all the FREE updates!

I recently signed up to be an agent at BzzAgent.   BzzAgent is very, very cool. 

Part of becoming a BzzAgent is that companies who have products or services that are interested in creating "Buzz" are matched with their target demographic.  The BzzAgents, then, receive free products to try out.  After some time, the BzzAgent creates an honest report of the service or product.   Several months ago, I intereviewed Sam Clemens of BzzAgent, and this is his explanation of their service:

Marketers (either product companies or their ad agencies) tell us who they are targeting and give us samples of the new product. We send those samples to the slice of our user “agent” base that matches the target demographic. Our deal with the agents is that if they like the product and talk about it, they need to tell us in a report so we can pass the feedback to the advertiser. They also need to say that they got the product from us (we get a lot of new agents this way). The agent gets a cool new product to try, the advertiser gets measurable word-of-mouth distribution, and everyone’s happy.

Pretty simple. 

My first campaign was to test Carbonite.  Through BzzAgent, I was given a 3 month free subscription to Carbonite.  Carbonite is an online PC backup service that, for a flat yearly fee, provides unlimited backups of your machine. Recommended by PC World and CNET.com, it works automatically in the background without slowing your computer or Internet connection (this is their claim).  If you’re interested in trying it out, I’m able to give free trials with no credit cards involved — so it’s totally risk-free.  Here’s the shpeal they provide me:

I just learned about a new service called Carbonite Online Backup that gives me peace of mind by automatically backing up all of the data on my PC, including my photos, documents, emails, financial records and music. Once I started thinking about how bad it would be to lose all of that stuff, I signed up for the service. Actually, it really wasn’t a tough decision, because thanks to BzzAgent, I’m trying it for free! You can try it free, too, with this special offer that I can send to my friends and family.  If you have a PC running Windows XP or Vista, and a high-speed Internet connection like DSL or cable, you can try a one-month free trial subscription. It takes most people only a few minutes to download the software and it starts working immediately to securely backup files over the Internet. You don’t have to put in your credit card to try it, so it’s really risk-free.  Be sure to enter offer code BZZ after you click on this link to sign up:  I’ll be interested to hear what you think!

  • Recommended by technology experts at PC World, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times and CNET
  • Simplicity and peace of mind for pennies a day
  • "Set and forget" automatic and secure online backup service
  • Automatically protects your all your data against crashes, theft, loss or damage
  • Risk-free trial – no credit card required
  • Only $49.95/year, for unlimited data backup
  • Works with PCs running Windows XP or Vista
  • Available online at carbonite.com or at major retailers nationwide including Staples and Comp USA

Moreover, Carbonite claims the following statistics on data loss:

  • 31% of PC users have lost all of their files due to events beyond their control
  • 40% of data loss is caused by hard drive failure; 29% is caused by human error
  • The average lifespan of a hard drive is 3-5 years, but all hard drives will eventually fail
  • Each year, 2 million notebook computers are reported stolen
  • 97% of stolen PCs are never recovered

So, on to my honest review.

The Review

I downloaded the Carbonite installer and it installed pretty seamlessly.  I was then prompted to backup folders or files and I selected two critical directories that I wanted to backup.  The data that I decided to backup amounted to 3.2 Gigabytes.  I started the backup and ~19 hours later, the backup was complete.  All during the backup, my system performance was not impacted at all. 

To identify the items you want to backup, you just have to right-click on the directory and a blue mark is made on the directory.  Here is an image of that process:

Below is the look-and-feel of the Carbonite control panel:

All in all, the service is really easy to use.  I just selected the items that need to be backed-up, then I move on with life.  It was easy to use; responsive; and, seemed reliable based on my short testing of the system.

Creating Buzz

I am friends with the guys at Mozy, a competitor to Carbonite.   I’m also familiar with Omnidrive, Nik’s company, another competitor in the backup space.  So, I have experience with 3 services in this very competetive market.   I created buzz by blogging about my honest experience and by emailing the guys at Mozy and at Omnidrive and 9 other friends also. 

Would I Recommend Carbonite?

Based on the service alone, sure.  It was super easy to use, with an attractive and usable interface.  Because this was a free-trial for me, I wasn’t concerned about the price.  But, given the competitors and the wide-range of prices, I imagine that some would be price-sensitive.  So, yes, I recommend Carbonite, but check out their fees and compare their fees with the other players in this space.

Personal Note: After reviewing Omnidrive, Carbonite, and Mozy, I can comfotably say that I prefer Mozy.

Enjoy this article? Please SUBSCRIBE to receive all the FREE updates!

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Tristan Rhodes February 11, 2007 at 10:07 pm

From my perspective, the two best options for remote backup are Mozy and Carbonite. They both offer unlimited backup for $5/month.

The biggest problem is that they only support Windows OS. They have plans to add OS X and hopefully Linux, but there is no ETA for this. That is what is keeping me from signing up.

Bunny May 29, 2008 at 2:30 am

I would enjoy hearing your pros and cons on both Mozy and Carbonite and then how you came to the decision that you prefer Mozy (i.e., faster, more user friendly, nicer looking, better customer service, better pricing). I am seriously honing in on Carbonite but want to get as much feedback as possible, whether it be positive or negative.

I actually got a 1 month free offer, for Carbonite, through a radio program. If I decide at the end of 1 month to purchase the product they will add 2 extra months to either a 1 year or 2 year purchase. I almost forgot I had it until they sent me an email.

Thanx,

^Bunny^

eric August 10, 2009 at 2:57 pm

Carbonite rocks ive only had trouble with mozy for the 2 years ive used it i always had to do updates or i would get error messages “unable to connect to server” carbonite is a dream my computer doesnt even slow down when the back is in progress. use both you’ll see i’m right

James February 6, 2010 at 5:22 pm

I tried Mozy for my small business and was happy with them. I needed online backup for my personal computer and at the same time stumbled upon a Carbonite coupon “CRANK” for 15 day free trial and 2 months free when you sign up. I think I might give it a try. Any opinions?

Susan Doyle March 8, 2010 at 8:43 pm

I see from the internet that you reviewed Carbonite and recommended it. You should know that Cabronite does not deliver what they promise.

I had serious computer problems last spring (2009) and Carbonite worked as promised. I was grateful.

In mid-February 2010, more computer problems led to a new hard drive. Long-story-into-short, Carbonite had not backed up my vital .pst file (email, contacts, calendar) since the prior September!!! Carbonite on-line personnel could not help after substantial time on line. Then, their “escalation team” (who took days to call me) could not fix the problem and they could not tell me what had happened, but said it would not happen again. They told me there is no warranty or other remedy for their failure.

Since then, I gave up on the old computer (too many problems), got a new one and went to Carbonite to restore my files. Not only did Carbonite not restore my .pst file again, it also restored many, many old files that I had deleted months earlier and did not restore any of my work of the prior several weeks. The on-line people tell me they can’t help and they now are referring me AGAIN to the escalation team who AGAIN will contact me – leaving me hanging.

This is outrageous. If Carbonite does not back up their customer’s files (they do not dispute that I selected back up of all files) on a timely basis, they should not be in business. Youshould take real care about continuing to recommend this service. They do not stand by their product and the customer is left holding the bag when they fail.

Susan

Ira July 18, 2010 at 5:52 am

I hated Mozy. I went through 2 drive crashes in 2 years. Restoring files was painful and ungrateful experience. Their software would error out, cancel downloads, etc. Never again.
Mozy looks good as long as you don’t need to restore your whole computer.

Leave a Comment