You are here: Lean Six Sigma Home » Six Sigma » Unappetizing Spaghetti Diagrams

Unappetizing Spaghetti Diagrams

by Pete Abilla on August 9, 2009

Interested in a free 25+ eBook on the 7 Wastes? Please DOWNLOAD HERE.

A Spaghetti Diagram is a simple visual tool to demonstrate the flow of material, flow of information, and flow of money in a process. The word “spaghetti” is descriptive because it describes flow that is not easily understood, can’t easily be followed, or if the flow is literally all over the place.  Indeed, a Spaghetti Diagram represents a point-of-departure: what does the current state look like and what are the exact improvements we need to make?

Put another way, a Spaghetti Diagram is a visual representation of how bad things really are and are used to expose Waste and Opportunity.

How Bad are Things, Really?

Sometimes, through poor thinking and poor choices, Spaghetti Diagrams aren’t just representations of how things are, but they can be representations of what we have created: sometimes, we turn our processes into Spaghetti Diagrams; this is precisely the case with the U.S. Government and the current Healthcare Debate.

The Democratic Party’s proposed Healthcare scheme is below 1:

This map begs several questions:

  • Where does it start?
  • Where does it end?
  • Are all motions equally important?
  • What are the value-added steps?
  • What are the steps we can do without?
  • Can a 15 year old understand what is happening on this map?

It is safe to conclude that the map above is clearly bloated — complexity at its worst.

For me, I have a question that drives clarity and honesty in my thinking:

Can a 15 year old understand this?

If the answer is “No”, then I need to work harder to make my idea clearer and simpler.  Using that question as a litmus test for the Healthcare Scheme above, I believe the answer would be a clear “No.”  In other words, the Map above is a starting point, not an ending point: there is much to improve.

One area not exposed by either of the above maps is, perhaps, the most insidious of all: amidst all the confusion and motion are people that could potentially be harmed.  The patient is the true casualty in either of the above maps: she gets lost in it — indeed, we forget that at the center of Healthcare is the patient.  Broken processes enable our forgetfulness of people.

Broken process unfortunately helps us to forget people

Another map worthy of Spaghetti-like accolades is below 2:

Again, the presence of many squiggly lines means one thing: OPPORTUNITY for improvement.  This is clearly a starting point, not and ending point.  There is so much to improve.

To be fair, creating a future-state of the above is not trivial, underscoring the fact that Healthcare is clearly complex.  One thing is clear, if anything needs and begs improving, it is Healthcare where the biggest opportunities lie 3.

  1. Source: House of Representatives
  2. Source: The New Republic
  3. Credit to Kevin for the inspiration

search terms for this article:

spaghetti diagram, broken process, spaghetti diagrams, spaghetti diagram lean, spaghetti process, diagram spaghetti, hospital spaghetti diagram examples, health care center PLAN, diagrama spaghetti Six Sigma, broken processes, spaghetti diagram software, spaghetti diagram examples, U S lost healthcare, spaghetty diagram, spaghetti diagram healthcare, sipoc diagram for material flow, spaghetti diagram for healthcare, spaghetti diagram examples in hospital, spaghetti diagram health, SIPOC diagramming, six sigma lean process diagram in healthcare, spaghetti diagram example, six sigma spaggetty diagram example, spaghetti chart diagram example healthcare, spaghetti as is diagrams, spaghetti, spaghetti diagram in healthcare, spaghetti diagram meaning, wing chun dummy plans free download, what is a spaghetti map, what is a spaghetti diagram, warehouse spaghetti chart diagram, us government diagram, starting a process map from another map, spaghetti diagram map, spaghetti process map, spaghetti diagramming, spaghetti diagram tool, what is a speghetti diagram, spaghetti diagram school, Диаграмма «спагетти» (spaghetti chart) Тойота, sipoc diagram call center, healthcare spaghetti diagram, healthcare process maps, health care spaghetti diagram template, health care process map, free spaghetti diagram software, free spaghetti diagram for download, free information on spagetthie diagram for lean manufactoring, examples of spaghetti diagram process, example of spaghetti map, diagrams lean, 5s organization charts, diagrama de spaghetti toyota, developed spaghetti diagrams, democrat, broken process picture, hospital spaghetti diagram, images for spaghetti diagram for christmas, images of a broken process, SIPAGETTİ DİAGRAM, seis sigma diagramas de espagueti, restaurant organizational chart, process of spaghetti, process map examples spaghetti, Pictures Broken Process, lean spaghetti diagram, lean spagetti diagram generator, lean six sigma spaghetti diagram, Lean Sigma spaghetti diagram, lean methodology in healthcare Spaghetti Diagrams, lean healthcare spaghetti diagram, lean healthcare spagetti diagram, lean diagrama spaghetti, lean current and future state spaghetti diagram, another word for spaghetti diagram

Related Articles:


This post was written by

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Matt Williams August 10, 2009 at 6:09 am

Dan Roam has posted about this issue, specifically in respect of healthcare reform, and is going to be working on it himself – I’m looking forward to the results: http://digitalroam.typepad.com/digital_roam/2009/08/clarifiying-health-care-dont-expect-much-from-the-media.html

Reply

Chris P August 10, 2009 at 8:11 am

The first diagram was meant to be an explanation of the new plan, but as a statistician I am trained to ask, “Compared to what?” when I see data. I have yet to see a similarly designed diagram for the current system. If the point of the diagram was to show that this is a complex system with multiple points of regulation, then it has succeeded, but it is not evidence that the reform is worse than status quo.

Reply

Levi August 10, 2009 at 9:40 am

You should note that the diagram in question was created by Republican Staff Congressman Kevin Brady, who is the ranking Republican on the committee. Do you think he intended to portray the plan as clearly as possible, or did he perhaps want to make it look as confusing as possible?

No doubt the plan itself is very complex, but one must be careful to distinguish a bloated and complicated *representation* of the plan from the plan itself. Taking a representation designed by an opponent of the plan as the simplest possible representation is probably a bad idea.

Reply

Robert Edward Cenek August 10, 2009 at 3:28 pm

Ditto to Chris P and Levi. No more complicated than the current system.

Reply

Michael Donegan August 14, 2009 at 12:16 pm

psabilla, Could you please contact me concerning you Wharehouse article kast year. I am writing a business plan and have some questions. Thanks

Reply

Leave a Comment